While the trend of post-credit scenes and ambiguous endings often hints at potential sequels, some films simply don't require them. "The Greatest Showman" (2017), which tells the true story of circus master P.T. Barnum, concluded satisfactorily. Nevertheless, the film's impressive box office earnings of $435 million sparked discussions of a sequel, even though Barnum's story seemed complete. The director of The Greatest Showman confirmed these plans, showing that financial success can drive the continuation of a story.

The Greatest Showman 2 Cast: Will Zac and Hugh Be Back?

On "The Graham Norton Show" on April 26, Zac Efron hinted at a possible sequel by mentioning, "Hugh (Jackman) is involved in various projects, including a one-man show. What's next? I'm not sure, but I hope there is a sequel."

However, whether Hugh Jackman will return remains uncertain. Although Efrons comments suggest potential plans, Jackman himself told BBC Radio 2 that he "knows" producers are "working on a treatment" for a sequel to "The Greatest Showman." He added, "The real answer is 'could be.' I'm not sure. To be completely honest, there is talk, but nothing definitive... They're working on a treatment."

Jackman speculated, "I would love to be part of it, but I don't know if it would focus on my character. Also, remember, it took eight years to make the original, and it wasn't just about convincing people. Writing takes time."

The Greatest Showman 2 Plot: What's the Story?

Considering that "The Greatest Showman" presented a complete narrative arc, a direct sequel doesn't immediately seem obvious. However, Barnum's rich life offers numerous aspects that could be explored in a film.

That said, not all parts of his life naturally fit the musical style fans expect from "The Greatest Showman." For example, his two terms in the Connecticut legislature don't lend themselves to the same song-and-dance treatment as the circus (cue a joke about politics being a circus).

If they could create an engaging and entertaining political musical in the spirit of "The Greatest Showman," it would undoubtedly be impressive.

Another intriguing aspect of Barnum's life was his tendency to debunk spiritualists and mediums. A story focusing on his efforts to expose hoaxes could make for an entertaining film.

The sequel may centre on Zac Efron's fictional character, Phillip Carlyle, with Hugh Jackman returning in a supporting role, allowing the story to delve further into fantasy. Alternatively, it could explore a side story set during the first film, focusing on a specific incident from Barnum's time running the circus.

Despite the criticisms that the original film faced for glossing over Barnum's more unsavoury traits, the sequel is unlikely to address these issues. While Barnum did eventually support the abolition of slavery, he undeniably exploited people of colour and the show's "freaks" to amass significant wealth.

If "The Greatest Showman 2" addresses the first film's criticisms regarding its portrayal of the truth, it would be quite a surprising achievement.

Admittedly, the original film took considerable liberties with the facts of Barnum's life for entertainment. Many characters, including those played by Efron and Zendaya, were fictional. Additionally, Barnum was not an orphan and had no romantic involvement with Jenny Lind.

Therefore, it wouldn't be surprising if the sequel also strays significantly from the truth. Jackman and Gracey seem more focused on delivering an entertaining show.